Duke Divinity Call & Response Blog

Read. Discuss. Imagine.

  • Print
February 9, 2010

James Howell: Church growth via luck

Way too often, “successful” clergy speak in easily decipherable code: “This church was a bit stale and had 100 members until 2003, and now we have 3,000 members and are doing cool stuff.” Translation? “I arrived, rather messianically, in 2003.” The commonly used disclaimer, “God has done amazing things since 2003,” doesn’t ameliorate how uncharitable to one’s predecessor, and how patently arrogant, this kind of talk can be. So very American, so unlike Paul’s weakness and trembling, light years from Jesus being deserted by whatever following he had mustered come the hour of crucifixion.

So now with some considerable embarrassment, I have been asked to tell you that when I came to Davidson United Methodist Church in 1991, there were 400 members, and when I left 12 years later there were 3,500. Was I messianic? Or brilliant?

Or just lucky?

I do not recall anyone talking about the role of “luck” in church growth, but it is quite real. If you want to grow a church rapidly, you’re lucky if you land a job in a quaint location with housing developments sprouting up all around, and unlucky if you land in, say, Detroit, Michigan right now.

But there is more. My first week in Davidson, I was running some errands downtown and bumped into a husband and wife. They spoke to me out of the blue, not I to them in some evangelical outgoingness. Turned out they were the first family to move into what became a 1000 home development -- and they were fantastic looking, gregarious, the kind of people other people simply wish to be around for dinner, tennis, and even church. After learning I was the new minister, they said “What the heck, we’ll try you on Sunday.” They came, joined, and invited the next person who moved in, and the next -- and soon we had a monopoly on a neighborhood.

Total luck. What if that first couple had been cantankerous and high maintenance? That whole neighborhood would likely have gone to the dark side: Presbyterianism. And it really is luck. Don’t give me that “God placed them in your path.” God has placed so many difficult people in my path, and has sent so many prickly people who have blunted the good work of the Kingdom of God that it seems laughable to chalk up a good-looking couple to God. It was just luck.

There were other “luck” factors -- not the least of which is what I’d call the “cool” factor. When a Church starts growing, Americans, being the trendy consumers that we are, get wind of the latest, coolest, fad congregation, and that’s where we want to be. Profound holiness, sacrificial ministry, and wise preaching can be happening down the street, but momentum builds around the cool place to be, and they keep coming.

During my days in Davidson, I strove valiantly to be holy, sacrificial, and wise. But what do I make of the growth? Certainly I celebrate. But was I really a superior evangelist, or strategist, or leader? Who could know such things? But I do know, for sure, that I was lucky, or we were lucky, and luck is a bit ephemeral, and of a piece with life in this world, where we strive to follow Christ with -- what else? -- utter humility or not at all.

James Howell is senior pastor of Myers Park United Methodist Church in Charlotte, North Carolina, and author, most recently, of “Introducing Christianity: Exploring the Bible, Faith, and Life” (Westminster).


A breath of fresh honesty.

A breath of fresh honesty. Thanks.

Wonderful reflection

That's a really interesting reflection on the stuff we do as pastors and churches. We can do, do, do with no change in church membership what so ever. We can be at peace, be at peace, be at peace at have no change in numbers as well. And THEN, we can take either of those postures and grow in numbers like crazy. Who can figure? I think luck is a good thing.

Luck and Church Growth

There is no doubt in my mind that where we are plays a significant role in what may or may not happen in our congregation. To be in a town where a factory closes and 3,000 are thrown out of work is more than unlucky, it is devastating to the whole community much less to growing a church. That is not say that a church can't have a hugely important and significant ministry in such a community - it does and should, but numerical growth may not result.
I do want to add however, that there is a place, beyond the grace and providence of God, for good, smart, hard work that makes a difference in a local church, including whether or not a church grows numerically. After all, even Paul commented on his work ethic in comparison with the other apostles, although as soon as he said it, he tried to ameliorate it by saying it wasn't him but God working through him.
Jesus tells us in John 15 we are called to abide in him and produce lasting fruit; I believe that means we are called to be both faithful and fruiful in the fullest sense of that word.

Love the reflection -- bold & honest

I like the thought process he intiates in me. We really do have to watch the mentality that my "doing" causes the growth and at the same time watch out for being escapistis, where we take no responsibility to reach out at all. Really, what I wish is that we would just stop beating each other up and realize that growth and effectiveness don't ... See Morealways equate to higher worship attendance or more members. It can but doesn't always. Also, I apprciate the deference to previous work by others who came before him, that the Spirit moved in them to provide a place where the Spirit could move for growth for his place. I also like his frankness that too often we are fast to play into our own type of prosperity Gospel where God's blessing me because I'm growiung but not you . . . where fast to condemn it when we see it in the 700 Club and TBN crowd but what about the way we do it in the church through membership growth and attendance growth as out "propsperity"

Post new comment

Comment Policy

* required field